It has been more than a year since the launch of S&P Dow Jones Indices’ carbon efficient indices. How have the indices helped advance ESG investment in Japan?
Mona Naqvi – Senior Director, ESG Product Management, S&P Dow Jones Indices, shares her views on ESG investment and indices in Japan over the past year as well as her expectations for the future.

The S&P Global Carbon Efficient Index series reduces index carbon exposure while maintaining similar levels of risk/return to the parent benchmarks. Most notably, the index series also incentivizes behavioral change among companies by uniquely encouraging two things:

  • Greater corporate transparency by rewarding companies that disclose global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions with a 10% boost in index weight;
  • The diversification of company business models towards low carbon alternatives as companies seek to improve their standing in the index.

This latter is achieved by assessing the carbon performance of companies (based on Trucost GHG emissions data), sorting them into deciles within Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS) industry groups, and reweighting accordingly. However, since some industries are inherently more greenhouse gas-emitting than others, our methodology considers the spread of possible emissions within an industry group, and increases or decreases company weights by either a greater or lesser extent depending on how much a company can feasibly improve given current available technologies. For example, a highly carbon-efficient energy company in the top decile of the broad-ranging energy industry is likely to be far ahead of its peers and thus deserves a significant weight increase of 120%. Conversely, a media company in the top decile of the smaller-ranging media industry only receives a small weight increase of 20%, as it's only slightly ahead of its peers. Vice versa, a high-emitting energy company in the bottom decile would get a weight reduction of -90% versus just -15% for a media company in the same position (See Exhibit 1). As such, companies are incentivized to both disclose and decarbonize to boost their overall standing – to the extent that they are able to.

Exhibit 1: S&P Global Carbon Efficient Index Weighting Methodology

ce-carbon-weight-adjustments (002)

The S&P Global Carbon Efficient Index Series covers financial markets worldwide and offers market participants the opportunity to reduce their exposure to carbon risk. The methodology is also sector neutral, amounting to a carbon reduction of 20-50% relative to the parent benchmarks, within less than 0.55% of tracking error and comparable returns. Thereby demonstrating that there need not be an inherent trade-off between investment performance and decarbonization. In theory, the carbon performance of the S&P Global Efficient Carbon Index Series should also further improve over the long-term as companies adapt their behavior and as the indices continue to grow in popularity among market participants. Indeed, our initial results to date suggest that they are already heading in that direction.

In 2018, Japan's Government Pension Investment Fund (GPIF) selected two of the carbon efficient indices for its ESG investment portfolio – the S&P/JPX Carbon Efficient Index for Japanese equities, and the S&P Global Ex-Japan LargeMid Carbon Efficient Index for non-Japanese equities. As of the last rebalance, the S&P/JPX Carbon Efficient Index recorded a 21% decrease in GHG emissions intensity over the one-year period ending March 2019, while the S&P Global Ex-Japan LargeMid Carbon Efficient Index reduced its carbon exposure by approximately 34% over the same period. As for returns, the S&P/JPX Carbon Efficient Index gained 5.97%, while the S&P Global Ex-Japan LargeMid Carbon Efficient Index gained 7.08% over the past five years, ending September 2019, with tracking errors of 0.46% and 0.53%, respectively. Both indices performed slightly better than their parent benhcmarks.

Perhaps the most interesting result, however, is that there has been a significant boost in the number of companies disclosing their carbon emissions this year, in large part, due to the GPIF's selection of this innovative index series – with an additional 113 GHG-disclosing companies around the globe, 33 of which are based in Japan. Another interesting result is that the dispersion of the spreads of GHG emissions across GICS Industry Groups, upon which the weight adjustments are based, are stabilizing. There were no major changes to the classification of GICS industry groups as either "high", "mid", or "low" impact: defined by the spread of carbon emissions, where the bigger the spread, the higher the impact and the larger the resultant index weight adjustments, and vice versa (See Exhibit 1). However, there was just one exception: the Commercial & Professional Services Industry Group, which moved from "high" to "mid" impact, suggesting that the GHG-emissions intensities of companies within that industry group are already beginning to converge.

Now, more than ever, market participants acknowledge that the impacts of climate change on their investments cannot be ignored. But while institutional investors often claim the importance of low carbon and ESG investment approaches in general, it can be difficult for them to engage in these strategies due to their commitment to closely track market returns. The S&P Global Carbon Efficient Index series demonstrates that it is possible to target meaningful carbon reduction and incentivize systemic behavioral change, while at least maintaining the beta coefficient. For example, the S&P/JPX Carbon Efficient Index has almost the same level of risk and return as the TOPIX, its parent index. As such, any investors tied to the TOPIX can thus benefit from reducing their carbon exposure without compromising their fiduciary obligations. Indeed, the S&P Global Carbon Efficient Index series offers market participants across the globe – who might otherwise agonize over balancing their fiduciary responsibilities with sustainable investment returns – a convenient pathway for addressing climate risks.

About S&P Global Carbon Efficient Index Series: https://us.spindices.com/topic/carbon-efficient